Hoi4 shadow puppet not working It depends on what kind of allies you have in the peace conference. Yes - as far as I recall, I got Memel, then got Danzig for guarantees, got called in when the soviets invaded and defeated them, post war to spare on the garrison costs/manpower issues I released the kingdom of Livonia as a puppet and they took Memel with them. However now I’m unable to give my puppets the states I annexed back. All have failed, I just cannot change the graphics on the map. I'm trying to do the "Big Entente" achievement, but every forum post and YouTube video I find is so many patches old it can't be relied on. I am having the same problem. However, and I don’t know if this changed with the new update, but if you annex the territory then spawn the puppet manually, it becomes a regular puppet you can use as you please. 8. The ratio depends on the autonomy level of your puppet. Mine was just test run of Byzantine tho but rather not do same process completely again just because achievement didnt fire. Democratic AI will puppet (supervised state) the cores and liberate non-core territories. Mar 10, 2020 · It was patched, but it still does work somewhat. Only the lowest level of the "standard" puppet scale (Integrated Puppet) gives you any of their factories; Fascist countries get factories from the second-lowest and more from the lowest; and collaboration governments give you a whole 75% of their civilian and military factories. Guess we have to wait week till they bring the usual bug patch. Business, Economics, and Finance. !!DO NOT PUPPET IN PEACE DEAL!! It is better to annex and release as puppet because then that nation inherit all your templates, laws, and research. You need your puppet to have ~10x the manpower of the final division you want to recruit. You can simply justify in the buffer state to get at the main combatant (a la France via Belgium) Guys, a lot of you stated that he's missing some Japanese cores, but that does NOT matter for this specific achievement. Your puppet's 'level' needs to be one where they contribute most, but not all, of the unit's manpower (e. Most efficient peace deal is feeding a puppet their core provinces. Oct 26, 2023 · Summary Puppet Japan as Sweden not working. This change was after La Resistance Reply reply I had the same Problem, just annex them per together for victory puppet system, release them as a free country, take the focus "Unite the Anglosphere" and puppet them IN THE PEACE CONFERENCE then and only the the you can take the decisions hope it works It is because whenever Yugoslavia joins the Axis, a coup happens, and if it goes without bloodshed, (or a war for that matter) then they will leave the Axis, and the game thinks that they are no longer your puppet. This trick requires a lot of puppet manpower and a lot of infantry equipment. Jun 29, 2022 · Does shadow puppet still work hoi4? Can you free puppet hoi4? Hearts of Iron 4 strategy or exploit: Shadow Puppet and cheap puppets; Images related to the topicHearts of Iron 4 strategy or exploit: Shadow Puppet and cheap puppets Most of the time when I capitulate the UK and France (all majors in the Allies), in the peace deal I can only get their land and not Canada's, India's, South Africa's etc. Given there is no such thing as a neutral puppet in HOI4 the Devs decided to not longer make Vichy France a German Puppet by default. Liberating only 1 locks the other out of the rest of the conference as a country that you can give states to. Once they capitulate try to take one of their coastal states (I think luga is the cheapest). Germany and italy are not at war with china so china lets their lend lease go through. So I made France and the UK as puppets after I defeated them and because Italy likes to seize a lot of territory I took border states and the ones they seem to like taking the most. If you were the puppet instead, you would lose your divisions upon their creation and they would go to your master. So the game just truly forgot to remove the Puppet icon. Open up your division designer, at the top right you'll see a crown, click the crown, you can see your Puppet's templates. 1. It's not a "shadow puppet" because they actually do have a province somewhere, but it serves a similar function. no_name7007 • General of the Army • Additional comment actions The official unofficial subreddit for Elite Dangerous, we even have devs lurking the sub! Elite Dangerous brings gaming’s original open world adventure to the modern generation with a stunning recreation of the entire Milky Way galaxy. I've tried uninstalling the mods, verifying files, clean reinstall of HOI4, using different mods. I sent them volunteers and air wings. Crypto 1 Is Tannu Tuva your puppet? 2 Most achievements need a day or so to load and fire 3 Just spam release, sometimes it's a must. Both option do basically the same, it just depends on whether the target nation was free or a subject by the time of the peace deal. The colours simply don't change anymore, and I have no idea why. :P The game seems to remember your division count. But sometimes it lets me take their land too. So, sorry. To make it very, very short, a puppet can be a great way to access more resources and also a puppets manpower pool to create. When I went to use the satisfying puppet and country names mod and it didn't change. e. I alos noticed that whenever you would make a nation someone's puppet, and the exact popularities of every single ideology is not specified in the code of said nation, communist popularity is around 30%, even though there is nothing related to communism in the nation's code. integrated puppets or satellites won't work) Step 1: Recruiting the fodder In that video he says that he doesn't like to puppet turkey because they can do weird things, but because I really didn't feel like defending and garrisoning the land I went against it. This has been across multiple patches so its definitely not a one time bug. God help the world if they do the same with all of China! I know it can work because I did it in 1938 despite taking a few detours on the focus tree and did not even get the Imperial Conscription because it was suppose to be my ironman commie UK run which went pearshaped. Platform Steam Operating System Windows 11 Game Version 1. Bug 2: "Puppet master can assist with supply up to" not working for naval bases & supply hub I'd like for there to be a tiered subject system you can work through like in hoi4's Together For Victory DLC. It just does nothing. Since you're Portuguese Republic, it will be democratic. After taking all the land I want I gave land to my "puppets" by clicking their flag below mine in the peace conference and giving each of them their core territories that I didn't want. So you can feed your puppet all its cores. I've seen videos before where you can edit their templates, but I can't figure out how myself. On top of that, I've also seen that with some puppets, they create divisions for themselves to use and control, which is what I prefer. Why did you remove shadow puppeting from hoi4? It prevented disgusting looking borders, prevented pointless weak satellites made by ia and helped with interesting challenges with smaller countries. For artists, writers, gamemasters, musicians, programmers, philosophers and scientists alike! The creation of new worlds and new universes has long been a key element of speculative fiction, from the fantasy works of Tolkien and Le Guin, to the science-fiction universes of Delany and Asimov, to the tabletop realm of Gygax and Barker, and beyond. It weird because i have another Soviet run but this time no Ironman and the puppet act normal, in fact, they spam out a lot more divisions than normal. My Japanese puppet isn't in my faction and is in a civil war (probably related to failing in China a while back) Playing as France and I’m trying to give control of some of my controlled area in Italy to my Italian puppet. The official subreddit for discussing Idle Champions of the Forgotten Realms, a Dungeons & Dragons strategy video game that brings together D&D characters from novels, adventures, and multiple live streams into a single grand adventure. e52a (3f99) Enabled DLC Do you have mods enabled? No Description Every decision that wants you to increase Support in a province like Spanish Civili War, UK Black Shirts, Romanias Divide Yugoslawia, doesn't work. Netdata collects metrics per second & presents them in low-latency dashboards. Sometimes the drop may not instantly happen due to many factors so just w8 it out but if it days since the command got executed but still no drop, it could be a bug w/ ur game or the requirements did not meet during the time u pressed the button. Hi all. On the other hand, you get less industry from their territories. Air Superiority can fluctuate if it is 70%. Ceasars allows more manpower, while Brotherhood and Vault city allow the puppets to get access to civilized tech. Puppets can provide you with troops and manpower. the 0 cost inaccessible desert tiles for Italy), take all states, un-take just the cheapest province, puppet, then manually un-take all the other states. Periodically, puppets that are sufficiently low autonomy (Integrated puppets and similar) will create units that come directly under the overlord's control. Edit : Figured it out. This can be done by basically doing the exact same thing as you would do as a puppet, just the other way around. No pop up telling it failed or anything. Also puppets don't have to be called into wars. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by… Well this is not true considering that Vichy forces actively fought against the allies since 1940, in Syria, Senegal, Madagascar, Mers-el-kebir and probably other places I don't remember rn. Mar 16, 2019 · You don't have extra trade influence when trading with your puppet/integrated puppet, the same applies for your relationship with your puppets, before I remember that there is an automatic +100 where your puppet is forced to "like" you and you have more trade influence over them because they are your puppet. If one has it (most likely the russian one) it's not the 'original' russia which does mean there's another russia (puppet or independent) which has the SOV tag. The new puppet will essentially the same as the Republic of Spain but by another name (in this case it'll be called Portuguese Spain). Click "Copy" and you can then build puppet divisions using their manpower but your equipment. Puppet doesn't need garrison - what allows to save up on manpower and weapons. I know in my last game and based on my comment when it was fresher, that the civil war was running out of men on both sides to hold the line so 1939 to finish up might be the new normal. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by… France changed turkey's goverment, its like puppeting, but not. 1 division training still works. If this country has puppets itself, you get the option to 'satellite' these. YOu probabl have something that would work. Maybe. so I am doing an Austria Hungary game in Iron Man, and lend leasing convoys to my puppets don't repress their autonomy despite showing how much autonomy they'll lose in the operation Archived post. Seriously tho you dont need japan to help you in the civil war it's pretty ez if you know what your doing. This can raise your autonomy/your puppets autonomy, making them free after going through a few levels of indepency. If you want to avoid that, you'll need to just do better in war, so you can start at peace conference or hope that france will puppet turkey instead of changing goverments. Sep 18, 2024 · I need help with a really strange thing i bought hoi4 bundle when it was for sale like 2 years ago and for these 2 years i never realized that i have 3 dlcs because they are not showing up in the launcher and don't see any features of these dlcs when i was searching for a dlc to buy for the game i decided that clicked on the dlc waking the tiger and it showed me that it's in my library but it Puppets : in designer you can look at, copy, and produce puppet divisions as your own and get up to 90% of a puppets full manpower. It worked, and I was able to set up the puppets how I liked them. All of it in South America. . It's been about 6 months and 2 dlcs ago since I played as the USSR and it might have taken that long for them to take Soviet aid. Then you deselect all the a land you choose for annexation and press "End Turn". (Correct me if i'm wrong but I think there's a war of independence focus) Also, puppets can be used to block enemies by not calling them into war, you get a lot more resources per factory while trading with your puppets, they can use their focus tree to get factories (so it is a good idea to release african colonies, to annex them later - you will get the territory and bonus factories and infrastructure for free) Just because it didn’t work doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be an actual mechanic in a game that seeks to simulate history. 1 (dd56) & Battle for the Bosporus Enabled DLC Together for Victory, Death or Dishonor, Waking the Tiger, Man The Guns, La Resistance Do you have mods enabled? No Description The national focus The Pan-National Association of Ulemas for Turkey does not result in puppeting anyone Steps to The open-source observability platform everyone needs. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game… Skip to main content Hey all, in my most recent Germany game I ended up puppeting Zimbabwe and feeding the country a lot of land to have a nice looking "MittelAfrika", but the nation has 0 industry, and around 10k recruitable population. How do I stop being one? I don't have any DLCs either. Turkey - Puppet focus not working Game Version v1. g. 402K subscribers in the hoi4 community. After many tries to get the achievement, it was September of 1944, In 3 months the achievement would've fired. So its just a QoL feature for map painting that the puppets fall along their masters. Those states would sometimes still make a somewhat decent puppet. Likewise there is no workaround for it. OWB has custom puppet trees for Ceasars Legion, NCR, Brotherhood and Vault city. R5: Hi so I helped Spain to win the civil war and I remember that they should become a puppet if they win the war. One thing that could work is if you go to war with someone and youre not in a faction, your puppet could be annexed or puppeted by someone else if theyre capitulated. Cheapest way to get a puppet is to find the cheapest province of a country (i. Every time I try and give them states nothing happens. Now you have created a very cheap puppet. Feb 2, 2025 · Similarly, the subject lend-leasing equipment to the overlord will raise autonomy by 1 for every 100 production cost of the transferred equipment. I had 4% warscore. I used that to my advantage by making every guaranteed country of South America join the Axis, which led to the US not protecting them. Puppet divisions use a mixture of your and their manpower. I stole their gold and was in a war for a few months with Poland. In short, it's as if the divisions are automatically requested. 2 Use the focus to annex tannu tuva, release it and voila. Im assuming that as tanu tuva and your puppets you only border china and its faction and the ussr and its faction. Brand new HOI4 player here (from EU4), this might be a very dumb question but is the game just all one war? all the stuff i read seems to imply prepping for this one global war (wwii obv) but like, there's no free for all or anything you basically pick a side -> win/lose -> the end? 408K subscribers in the hoi4 community. you need to have THAT russia as your puppet. Feb 22, 2022 · Bug 1: Puppet supply cap actual lower than shown In the first image you can see that it shows that the supply cap from Bangkok (my puppet as Japan) is 22, however in reality I only receive 11 supplies from Bankok because I take some of his factories. Many nations can be puppeted for 0-5 points that way, blocking anybody else from using puppet/change government. Feb 17, 2019 · I recently won a war against the allies as France, and before doing anything "shadow puppeted" all the nations so that Japan couldn't puppet any of them. This is somehow confusing because 'puppet' and 'satellite' are also the names of some autonomy levels of subjects, as others already wrote. ; About Hearts of Iron 4 Wiki; Mobile view i specifically wanted the focus to work to prevent Romania from protecting Czechoslovakia. and any democratic country can annex another nation, then release as puppet as a work around. The USA staged a coup in Iran to put the monarch in power because oil, the UK installed a pro-Britain monarch to rule in Iraq after WW1 because oil, Japan was effectively a US puppet state after WW2 until the end of the occupation, and democracies in the game already have many puppets (granted all of them were acquired further back in Mar 21, 2022 · Onworld Decisions not working Game Version 1. As a player though, it works exactly as expected. 0 unless otherwise noted. As other people have noted, definitely a consequence ( intended or otherwise) of the new way warscore and peace is handled. Puppets do not get your technology in general. So, if an imperialist Democratic, annex then decide. 11 Explain the reasoning behind this change: I've noticed that some of my puppets switched from occupied puppet to puppet without gain Then you select "puppet" in the cheapest core. Vichy was formally neutral, true, but not in practice and the game fails to represent such weird situation. What’s broken is that the AI never chooses to justify on the puppet. Paratroopers not working Question Hi Reddit, so I was playing Germany and going for a really quick world conquest, so I justified on France and built paratroopers in 1936 and I eventually I declared war, I got air superiority in Northern France where my paradrop orders were but they won’t go it says I can do it, I have transports in the air 1K votes, 22 comments. You can also use XP and modify their templates after copying, meaning you can make really powerful puppet divisions. If your puppet is bordering a bigger enemy that will declare on you but not on the puppet, you can keep the puppet out of the war and thus have a block between you and the enemy. 9. New to this sub and am looking for help. iirc, the mantra was 'annex if you want factories, puppet if you want manpower'. Like the units you can request, these will use the puppet's templates (and at first - equipment) so they are not much use aside from holding the line. Also they build factories in their own territories. It seems regardless of if they're in a faction with me or not they just sit back and guard their territory doing nothing even if they're not adjacent to the front. r5:I was playing the republic of france in kaiserredux and went the Napoleon path and conquered egypt and set up a puppet goverment and when I was at war with the ottomans my puppet left the faction I was apart of when the arab revolt happends and joined the cairo pact even though I was apart of the entente The problem with puppeting at the moment is just that the AI isn't good enough. Deleted some saves but still won't work. On the other hand, a ruler always tries to keep the puppet a puppet, or even annex it entirely. If literally anyone else, annex if developed and strategic land, puppet if underdeveloped and/or hard to defend. Feb 22, 2020 · Quick questions HOI4 version: 1. Just start a Soviet ironman run and all of my puppets has been useless. Now justify on Germany and set your garrisons for Poland to no garrison. I want to play as India/british raj but Im a puppet of the UK. (At least not to my knowledge) Edit: as someone pointed out pupped autonomy system is independent from the DLC and cannot be disabled. Hey guys, I'm having trouble puppeting as Japan. This is very annoying in cases of Bulgaria and Turkey, where bulgaria support the IMRO, or Turkey that occasionally leaves your faction, but sometimes they get default focus trees and behave. All that counts here is that you annexed whatever country has the JAP tag - which can hold all of its cores or be exiled to some island in the pacific or some random jungle in South America for that matter - via the puppet mechanic AND did not join a faction before doing so To be fair Democratic nations have "puppeted" nations irl. That and millions upon millions of lend lease offers. Played as the british raj, using console started a civil war with the other side being fascist, then tagged over to fascist india and using console I annexed the british raj effectively removing me as a puppet Make sure not to puppet them for manpower/navy because they may research nukes. r5 Was messing around in rt56 (new player so not in ironman) ended up going to war with Japan because of the former colonies of England and the netherlands, puppeted japan, went to war with China over india. Was thinking making a post about it. Steps to Reproduce You are using only the cheapest state to make the puppet. Need advice/strategy. Idk man, the yalta conference is buggy af and I don't like accepting it because u can get germany as a puppet which is better than Poland and u get to keep It if u can establish a collab gov before the allies cap Japan. Puppeting countries can often be safer than annexing them as it generates less World Tension than territorial annexation, reducing the risk of foreign intervention by other potentially hostile countries. It could be something like Independent -> Customs Union -> Protectorate -> Dominion -> Puppet -> Vassal -> Annexed Basically, I want Together For Victory 2 Together For Victoria, if you will. I was feeling pretty clever until I got to the Peace negotiation. i think it doesnt matter cause the game is "total war" and if you capitulate britain then the game is probably already over anyway, no matter if you have india or not. It's designed to run on all physical & virtual servers, cloud deployments, Kubernetes clusters & edge/IoT devices, to monitor your systems, containers & apps. It didn't matter regardless, they didn't, but neither Hungary or Romania became puppets, and remained independent with no event pop up. The equipment must be as good as the best the overlord can produce (or better), so draining a puppet of obsolete equipment does not weaken authority over the puppet. I don't have the ratios in my mind, but they should be shown in a tool tip. Each puppet has it's own focus tree, and if each puppet does their industrial focuses you get way more factories from many smaller puppets than one big puppet Reply reply BottleRocketU587 You can make some divisions with their manpower but you can't change their composition. What do I do? Feb 2, 2025 · Puppet can send garrison support to save up on manpower. R5: Playing as fascist Italy in Allies faction via Stresa Front focus, and the game has blocked the option to make any puppets in peace conferences, even when I was the only one in the war. Instead of taking all states, puppeting, and unselecting all states in order to get a puppet with zero cost, you can now select all states except the cheapest one, puppet and unselect all the other states in order to get a puppet with very low cost. 4 Enabled DLC All of the above Do you have Apr 23, 2023 · This page was last edited on 23 April 2023, at 03:11. Paratroopers not working Question When playing as Germany I use paratroopers to get a Naval base In the uk and then just send regular forces there to take over the rest of the island. This makes me feel like the whole system is useless unless in the case of my puppets i just commandeer their units. Isn't good enough for the enemy AI to whittle down your manpower to the point where you need the puppets' manpower to survive, and isn't good enough for the puppet AI to produce decent divisions to lend you or defend their own territory without your help. Other info related to puppets: A nation at war cannot invade a puppet of its enemy if he hasn't called it to arms However the master can use their in-peace puppets as bases to launch naval and air invasions (but not for land) as well for your air wings and fleets Supplies can still circulate through puppets even if they aren't involved step 3: load a new game and do it again and dont be a puppet of japan. Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. I have 3 mods in one of my playsets, Historical flags, different portraits and satisfying puppet and country names. Then you could proceed to defeat that enemy and do as you wish. Just puppet Nationalist Spain. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. So if you delete your army and only leave one division that "memory" will decay eventually (around 6 month to a year) allowing even UK, France, and Soviets to use 1 division training. 13. Trying to get a better grasp on how puppets and their divisions work. 408K subscribers in the hoi4 community. Declare on Germany, call in your polish puppet and let them capitulate to Germany while holding the rest of Poland the best you can. It's pretty game breaking if your puppet's puppet has a civil war as you can't intervene without justifying on the opposing side. Its completely worthless now, as you can't build in them. I have same problem, all required nations as puppets but nothing fired. Say for example, that the AI Soviet Union has the most warscore and has the first turn, then it will usually only puppet East Germany, making it a valid country that states and score can be given to in the conference, but not West Germany. If japan is at war with china they wont be able to let lend lease items through them and neither will the ussr for obvious reasons. When you puppet Nationalist Spain, the new puppet government will have the same ideology as your country. That can be useful if you for example play as France or Britain and you release a ton of useless land in Africa and those new nations get their generic focus tree and stuff it full of factories and you get access to some of them by being their master. I have… I've run into an issue with HOI4 which affects all colour graphic changing mods, specifically Coloured Puppet related stuff. The HoI4 wiki has a great breakdown of how puppets work on different autonomy levels for different ideologies. Anyone know what’s going on? How do puppet focus trees work? I have noticed that sometimes puppets get the default focus tree and sometimes keep using their own. For example, technically the puppet's puppet isn't your puppet so you can't automatically call it to arms, request its divisions, or join its wars. Integrated puppets and lower levels will automatically hand over division control to their master. My whole game plan was kind of built around puppeting India but I can't seem to release them. Since a puppet already exists, democratic and communist AI will take very little land if at all. You should have a puppet for 0 warscore with no land, preventing the enemy from puppeting the country you just did. Tldr; struggling with "Big Entente" achievement. Exact same thing happened to me. Does anybody know why this happens and how to fix it? In the peace deal, take all of their states except one that borders Germany and puppet them there (I did Danzig for the achievement). Game will think you have a puppet and ignore all of that land which is free for you to take. They just forced them to beacome democratic. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Nov 16, 2022 · I've had it happen in every game as the UK when calling puppets into a war later rather than the initial join. Those trees replace the normal trees. But I'm allowed to change the German government from fascism to fascism? Not in the way you used to be able to, but in essence, it's still possible. Take out China once the Chinese provocation event fires, then declare on the soviets. UK is one of the few Democratic nations that can puppet in a peace deal, if you go down the 'Global Defense' path. everything else would be just annoying and simply not appealing gameplaywise. Content is available under Attribution-ShareAlike 3. EDIT: People please test what I am saying. 11. Since I was in a war every country that I attacked joined the opposite side. How does the supply work when attacking a country through a puppet, I have upgraded the rail lines for them even connected to my capital but I still… Check if any of your puppets has the generic focus tree. 10. Importing resources from puppets is super cheap because you get significantly more per factory. Puppets give you a portion of their manpower and factories. It appears on the map but it doesn't respond to clicking on it. I will say though, at least in my case it seemed to actively be cheaper to directly conquer DEI than to puppet, which does not seem right and could be a bug. I am a little dissapointed with this new update of the game However, you can still puppet in cheap areas by taking all states except one (african desert, siberia, low-quality china tiles). Otherwise the new autonomy puppet system kicks in and in there you cannot manually release a puppet. 2 Kaiserreich version: 0. Click "puppet" take all states, then untake all states. Not in a peace conference btw. rjhyrty vqb empbag uiqnydr hswflcar edctubt sapzd olvqhto nfnffh igqcao apcs gnqr vduui vuuc tcfrga